bux-lang/docs/superpowers/specs/2026-06-10-drop-trait-design.md

Drop Trait / Destructors Design Document

Date: 2026-06-10
Status: Superseded — see 2026-06-14-drop-interface-auto-drop-design.md
Scope: Selfhost compiler (src/*.bux)

1. Problem Statement

The @[Drop] attribute and auto-drop mechanism already exist in the selfhost compiler, but they are restricted to @[Checked] functions only. This means regular (unchecked) code does not receive automatic cleanup for resource-holding types. The programmer must manually call TypeName_Drop() or use defer.

This is inconsistent with the goal of making Bux "safe by choice" — if a type declares it needs cleanup (@[Drop]), that cleanup should happen regardless of whether the function is checked.

2. Goals

1. Universal auto-drop: @[Drop] types are automatically cleaned up when they go out of scope in all functions, not just @[Checked] ones.
2. Preserve move semantics: Variables that have been moved are NOT double-freed (existing CBE_IsMoved logic stays).
3. No breaking changes: Existing code continues to work; we only add cleanup where it was previously skipped.
4. Selfhost loop compatibility: The compiler must still bootstrap deterministically after these changes.

3. Non-Goals

1. own T type: Adding own T to the selfhost type system is a separate, larger feature. This design works with the existing value-semantics + @[Drop] model.
2. Scoped defers on break/continue: The selfhost C backend currently does not emit defers on break/continue (unlike bootstrap). Fixing this is tracked separately.
3. Drop trait interface dispatch: Auto-drop uses static lookup of TypeName_Drop, not interface vtables. This is intentional — zero runtime cost.

4. Architecture

4.1 Before (Current)

// hir_lower.bux:1118-1139
if ctx.checkedFunc && !String_Eq(alloca.typeName, "") {
    // build auto-drop defer
}

Only checked functions get auto-drop.

4.2 After (Proposed)

// hir_lower.bux:1118-1139
if !String_Eq(alloca.typeName, "") {
    // build auto-drop defer
}

All functions get auto-drop for @[Drop] types.

4.3 How It Works

1. Parser: @[Drop] attribute on struct → decl.isDrop = 1
2. HIR Lowering (hir_lower.bux):
   • When lowering a let binding, after the hStore/ hAlloca:
   • Call Lcx_BuildAutoDropFree(ctx, typeName) to find the drop function name
   • If found, wrap it in hDefer and append to statement chain
   • Remove the ctx.checkedFunc gate
3. C Backend (c_backend.bux):
   • CBE_EmitDefers already handles:
     • LIFO order
     • Skip moved variables (CBE_IsMoved)
   • No changes needed in C backend

5. Affected Files

File	Change
src/hir_lower.bux	Remove ctx.checkedFunc && condition on line 1120
_test_drop_user/src/Main.bux	Remove @[Checked] from test to verify universal drop
_test_drop_trait/src/Main.bux	Fix syntax (already broken — module Main; + indexing)

6. Testing Plan

6.1 Existing Tests

Test	Expected
_test_drop_user	Should pass WITHOUT @[Checked]
_test_drop_move	Should still skip drop for moved vars
selfhost-loop	C output must remain identical

6.2 New Test (Optional)

Create _test_drop_universal/src/Main.bux:

@[Drop]
struct Resource {
    id: int
}

var dropCount: int = 0;

func Resource_Drop(self: *Resource) {
    dropCount = dropCount + 1;
}

func Main() -> int {
    // NOT @[Checked]
    let r: Resource = Resource { id: 1 };
    // r should be auto-dropped here
    return dropCount;  // expect 1
}

7. Risks & Mitigations

Risk	Mitigation
Existing unchecked code now gets implicit drops	This is the intended behavior. Types with @[Drop] explicitly opt-in.
Performance impact from extra defer calls	Minimal — defers are inlined as direct C calls. No runtime overhead.
Selfhost loop breaks	Test make selfhost-loop before committing.

8. Future Work

1. own T in selfhost: Add own T type expression + move-on-pass semantics (like bootstrap).
2. Scoped defers on break/continue: Match bootstrap behavior.
3. Drop trait interface check: Verify at compile time that @[Drop] types actually implement Drop interface (has TypeName_Drop method).

9. Placeholder Scan

• No TBD/TODO placeholders.
• All file paths are exact.
• All code is copy-paste ready.